Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Maxing out retirement accounts like a 401(k) and Roth IRA is often hailed as one of the smartest things young professionals can do for their future. You’ve probably heard the advice before: Start early, let compound interest work its magic, and you’ll be a millionaire by retirement. On the surface, that sounds like a no-brainer.
I followed that advice. I diligently maxed out my 401(k) and Roth IRA every year in my 20s. My retirement accounts look solid now with over 500k split between IRA and a Roth IRA, which is great — on paper. But I’m facing a different kind of financial challenge: I don’t have enough liquid cash to make big purchases like a bigger home or unexpected medical expenses. My money is tied up in accounts I can’t access without penalties.
If you’re a young professional or in your early 30s, you might want to think about it first before maxing out your retirement contributions. Here’s why.
1. Retirement Accounts Are Not Liquid
One of the biggest drawbacks to loading up retirement accounts early is that the money is locked up. A 401(k) and Roth IRA are designed to be accessed at age 59½ or later. Yes, there are exceptions and loopholes — like the Roth IRA’s first-time homebuyer exemption or 401(k) hardship withdrawals — but they’re limited, complex, and often come with strings attached.
If you need a down payment on a home or find yourself facing a large, unexpected expense (like medical bills or job loss), that retirement money isn’t readily available. You might end up draining your emergency fund, simply because your assets are locked away in retirement vehicles.
I still have 20 years before I reach age 60 and after getting laid off again I finally realized why I shouldn’t have tried to max out every year. I understand I was lucky enough to live rent free until age 32, but I shouldn’t use that as an excuse.
2. You Might Sacrifice Short-Term Life Goals
When I was maxing out contributions, I felt proud and responsible — and in many ways, I was. But I didn’t realize I was making trade-offs that would come back to haunt me.
I postponed upgrading to a bigger home, thinking that I’d have enough money, but with how fast home prices are rising I don’t believe the current savings I have will be enough. I’m in a much tougher spot than I would have been had I saved in a more flexible account. I also had a new baby with my wife in 2024 and needed a bigger car to accommodate another family member, so that purchase basically cut down a big part of my savings goal for a bigger home.
The result? I’ve had to delay purchasing a bigger home altogether while my retirement accounts continue to grow. That’s a frustrating paradox.
3. You Lose Flexibility and Optionality
Financial flexibility is a hugely underrated asset in your 20s and 30s. Maybe you’ll want to switch careers, go back to school, start a business, or move to a different city or country. All of these moves require accessible capital. When your net worth is concentrated in retirement accounts, you lose optionality.
For example, if a fantastic business opportunity arises and you need startup capital, you can’t just dip into your 401(k) without facing penalties and taxes. That limits your ability to respond to new opportunities or to pivot when life changes.
Retirement accounts come with rules and restrictions — which are great for keeping you disciplined, but less great when life throws curveballs.
4. You May Not Maximize Employer Matching Efficiently
Maxing out your 401(k) early in the year might sound great, but if your employer’s match is done per paycheck rather than annually, you could actually lose out on free money. Some companies only match contributions when you contribute — so if you hit your max by mid-year, the match stops there.
In hindsight, a more balanced approach would have been to spread out my contributions throughout the year to maximize employer matching benefits. It’s a small detail, but one that can add up significantly over time.
5. You Miss Out on Other Investment Opportunities
While retirement accounts offer tax advantages, they’re not the only way to grow wealth. Taxable brokerage accounts, real estate, and even high-yield savings accounts or CDs provide opportunities to build wealth and maintain liquidity.
When I focused solely on retirement vehicles, I missed years of potential investment returns in other areas. A taxable brokerage account could have allowed me to invest in index funds while still being able to access the funds when needed — no penalties, just taxes on gains. That flexibility would have made a huge difference.
6. Early Career Income Isn’t Always Stable
In your 20s and early 30s, your career and income can fluctuate — job changes, layoffs, or time off are common. Maxing out retirement contributions during these years might stretch your budget too thin and leave you vulnerable if your income takes a hit.
I found myself tapping into my savings during a brief period of unemployment in 2014 and 2023. Meanwhile, my retirement accounts sat untouched and untouchable. Had I put more money into an emergency fund or flexible investments, I could have navigated that period with far less stress.
7. The Psychological Impact of “Being Broke” Despite Saving
There’s a strange psychological tension when you see five or six figures in your retirement accounts but feel cash-poor in everyday life. You’re technically doing the “right” thing, but it doesn’t feel right. You might feel trapped, stuck, or like you’re failing at adulting — even when you’re financially responsible.
This disconnect can create financial anxiety or burnout. After years of living frugally to max out contributions, you might start to resent the process or become tempted to take on debt just to enjoy life a little. A more balanced approach would have provided peace of mind along the way.
Looking back, I kind of regret maxing out every year because now I barely have any savings to keep my family afloat. I am currently relying on my spouse to help support the family while I navigate through this tuff event.
8. You Don’t Know What Retirement Will Look Like Yet
Retirement planning is essential, but the reality is that your vision for retirement will likely evolve over time. You might not want to retire traditionally — maybe you’ll pursue part-time work, consulting, or even early retirement through other means.
When you focus too much on traditional retirement accounts, you assume that your financial future will follow a conventional path. But life rarely works that way. Having money in flexible accounts can give you the ability to shape your future on your terms.
So What’s a Better Strategy?
None of this is to say you shouldn’t save for retirement. You absolutely should — and starting early still gives you a huge advantage. But balance is key.
Here’s a more nuanced approach I wish I had taken:
- Contribute enough to get your full employer match — that’s free money.
- Prioritize building a strong emergency fund with 12 months of living expenses. It use to be 6 months, but I encourage 12 given how the economy and job market is.
- Save for medium-term goals in a high-yield savings account (Ally or Sofi) or taxable brokerage account (Robinhood, Fidelity, etc).
- Split investments between retirement accounts and liquid options.
- Reevaluate your goals yearly and adjust your contribution strategy as your income and priorities evolve.
There’s nothing wrong with prioritizing liquidity and flexibility, especially in your 20s and 30s. Having cash on hand gives you power — the power to seize opportunities, weather storms, and enjoy your life while you’re still young.
Final Thoughts
Maxing out retirement contributions can be a powerful wealth-building tool — but it isn’t always the smartest choice at every stage of life. If you’re early in your career, have other major financial goals, or want to keep your options open, you may benefit more from a diversified saving and investing strategy.
I don’t regret saving for retirement, but I do regret not thinking about the full picture. The advice to “max out your 401(k) and Roth IRA” is well-meaning — but like most one-size-fits-all financial advice, it ignores the nuance of real life.
Your 30-year-old self deserves a secure retirement. But your 30-year-old self also deserves the chance to buy a home, start a family/business, or take a dream vacation. You can — and should — plan for both.
