Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
A few months ago, a former colleague reached out to me. She had just received two job offers and was struggling to decide which one to accept. Her voice sounded both excited and exhausted—a mix I’ve come to recognize when someone is at a professional crossroads.
At first glance, it seemed like she genuinely wanted my advice. But as our conversation unfolded, it became clear: she had already made her decision. What she was really looking for wasn’t guidance—it was confirmation.
Still, I listened closely. After all, big decisions often benefit from being talked out, even if we already know the answer deep down.
The Two Job Offers
Let’s break down her options.
Offer 1: A position at a Bay Area university. Stable, prestigious, and with the rare promise of a pension. The catch? The salary was 50% lower than what she was making in her current role.
Offer 2: A similar role at a private company that manages bus services for schools. Same salary as she’s currently earning. No pension. No drop in lifestyle. Just a lateral move financially, with different responsibilities.
What fascinated me about this scenario wasn’t just the comparison of offers—but how people around her reacted. She said she’d spoken to a dozen friends and mentors. Their opinions were split right down the middle.
- Half said: “Take the university job. A pension is rare these days. It’s stable. It’s secure.”
- The other half said: “Stick with the higher-paying job because you can always find a new one.”
It was, in every sense, a classic case of pension vs. paycheck.
Because I have a background in finance, I couldn’t help but do some digging. I asked her how much the pension actually paid, and how long she’d have to stay to receive it.
That’s when the real math began.
The Pension: What’s It Actually Worth?
Here’s what she told me:
- After 10 years of service, she would qualify for a pension of around $14,000 per year.
- After 15 years, the pension would increase to about $24,000 per year.
Now, that’s not nothing. A guaranteed stream of income in retirement has value. In an era when most people are left to fend for themselves in the 401(k) wilds, a pension is like finding a unicorn in your backyard.
But here’s the catch: that pension came at a steep price.
To take the university job, she would need to accept a 50% pay cut—assuming her salary is $100,000 per year to $50,000 per year.
After taxes, the real reduction would be about $35,000 per year in take-home pay.
That’s a major hit. And not just in the abstract. That’s $35,000 each year that she wouldn’t be saving, investing, or spending on her life.
So the real question became: How much is that pension worth compared to what she’s giving up?
A Simple Comparison: Invest the Difference
Let’s imagine she took the private sector job with the same salary she earns now—$100,000—and invested the $35,000 per year that she would have otherwise lost by taking the lower-paying university job.
If she invested that $35,000 annually into an S&P 500 index fund with a 7% annual return, here’s what would happen over time:
- After 10 years: She’d have approximately $486,000.
- After 15 years: She’d have over $950,000.
Let that sink in.
Almost half a million dollars in 10 years. Nearly a million dollars in 15 years.
And keep in mind, this is money she controls—money that doesn’t require her to stay at a job for a decade to qualify, or depend on a pension plan staying solvent. It’s liquid. Flexible. And hers.
In contrast, the university pension would pay her $14,000 per year if she stayed 10 years. Or $24,000 per year if she stayed 15.
If we run the numbers and treat the pension like an annuity (a financial product that pays you a fixed amount for life), we can estimate the value of those pension payments:
- A $14,000/year pension might be worth around $280,000 in today’s dollars.
- A $24,000/year pension could be valued at around $480,000.
Even in the best-case scenario, the pension doesn’t match the potential investment value she could build by simply maintaining her higher salary and saving the difference.
The Hidden Costs of Stability
This brings us to a deeper truth: stability has a cost. And sometimes, that cost is steep.
The university job looked good on paper. Stability. A pension. Prestige. But beneath the surface, it demanded a major financial sacrifice—and a long-term commitment just to break even.
Now, I’m not dismissing the value of stability. For some, the peace of mind that comes with a pension and job security is worth more than an extra $35,000 a year. Especially if you’re risk-averse, approaching retirement, or burned out from the unpredictability of the private sector.
But for others—especially younger professionals or those who want financial flexibility—the numbers tell a different story.
It’s not about being greedy. It’s about being informed.
The Real Reason She Called
When I shared this analysis with her, there was a pause.
And then she admitted it: she had already accepted the private sector job.
She just wanted to know she hadn’t made a mistake.
And here’s the thing—I don’t think she did.
Sure, the pension had its appeal. And yes, there’s something comforting about working at a university. But once we walked through the actual numbers, she realized that the higher-paying job gave her more control, more options, and potentially a stronger financial future—if she was disciplined about saving and investing the difference.
That’s the key. The value isn’t just in earning more—it’s in what you do with it.
Lessons From the Crossroads
Here are a few takeaways from her situation that might help you the next time you—or someone you know—faces a similar decision.
1. Don’t Just Look at the Pension—Quantify It
A pension sounds great, but always ask: How much? When? What are the vesting requirements? A $24,000/year pension that requires 15 years of work might not be as valuable as you think when compared to what you’re giving up in the present.
2. Calculate the Opportunity Cost
In this case, the opportunity cost was $35,000 a year. That’s a big deal. Over time, that’s hundreds of thousands in lost earnings, investments, and compounded returns.
3. Emotionally, We Crave Confirmation—But We Need Clarity
It’s natural to seek reassurance after a big decision. But don’t mistake validation for wisdom. What you really need is clarity. If you’ve already made your choice, understand why you made it. That will give you peace in the long run.
4. Stability Isn’t Always Financial
Job security is one form of stability. But so is financial independence. Sometimes the ability to walk away, to pivot, or to retire early gives you a deeper sense of stability than a guaranteed job or pension.
Final Thoughts
My friend made the right call—for her. Not because one job was objectively better, but because she understood what she was truly giving up—and gaining.
Pensions are nice. Stability is nice. But they’re not free.
If you’re facing a similar decision, take a step back. Do the math. Consider your long-term goals. Run the numbers. And don’t forget to ask yourself: What am I really looking for—advice, or reassurance?
Either way, clarity is the best gift you can give yourself.
And in a world full of noise, that’s worth more than any pension.
